The 10 Best Coffee Syrups and Sauces to Flavor Your Brew 2023

Last updated on September 19th, 2023 by Alex Praytor

The right coffee syrup can turn a regular cup of coffee into a gourmet experience. But with hundreds of brands on the market, which syrups and sauces are best for your coffee? 

Torani Vanilla Coffee Syrup is our overall favorite for its rich flavor and just the right amount of sweetness. This brand has roots in Italy and is a staple among upscale coffee shops throughout the U.S.

Last update on 2024-12-04

We’ve rated these coffee syrups based on flavor, popularity, and quality. Whether you’re recreating Starbucks-style coffees at home or trying out the best coffee syrup combinations, we’ve got some excellent options in store for you. 

In our list of best coffee syrups, we’re also highlighting Starbucks-approved brands, delicious boutique syrups, vegan flavors, and sugar-free options.

---

Let’s look at these top 10 coffee syrups and sauces to decide which ones belong in your coffee bar. 

Our List of Top 10 Coffee Syrups and Sauces

#1. Best overall: Torani Vanilla Coffee Syrup 

Things we like:

• Clean and creamy vanilla taste
• Made with real cane sugar and cold-filtered water
• Natural flavors
• 2-year shelf life
• The clear syrup blends well into any color drink
• No high fructose corn syrup
• Certified women-owned small business
• Highly rated by customers
• Versatile flavor

Things we don’t like:

• Labeled and sold only in the U.S.

Review:

This Torani Vanilla Syrup tastes delicious and is our top pick out of these ten options. It also gets the most popular award with a 4.8-star rating of around 25,000 Amazon customers.

The Torani brand set up shop in the 1920s with syrup recipes from Italy. The original goal of their syrups was to create Italian sodas. However, it wasn’t long before the Torani brand made headlines as part of the world’s first flavored latte. 

This tasty Torani Vanilla Coffee Syrup uses natural flavorings and real cane sugar. It easily blends into iced and hot coffees. Many customers also enjoy adding a splash to a Dr. Pepper or Coca-Cola. The Torani brand is still family-owned and continues to set the bar high for its products. You can find their syrups in many gourmet coffee shops. Or you can bring a bottle (or four) home and create your own upscale coffee drinks.

Last update on 2024-12-04

#2. Best Starbucks sauce: Starbucks Fontana Frappuccino White Chocolate Mocha Sauce

No products found.

Things we like:

• 63 ounces of sauce
• Classic Starbucks flavor
• The container includes a pump
• Perfect for sweetening coffee or as a topping

Things we don’t like:

• Approximately 25 calories per pump of sauce.

Review:

Starbucks’ White Chocolate Mocha is one of its best-selling drinks on the menu. However, you can easily shell out five dollars or more for this decadent beverage in-store. Whether you enjoy it as a Frappuccino roast, hot, or iced, you can recreate your favorite flavor at home with Fontana’s White Chocolate Mocha Sauce. 

While you won’t find the Starbucks name on the label, the Fontana brand is widely known as the mastermind creator behind many Starbucks coffee syrups and sauces. This 63-ounce container includes a pump as a mess-free way to measure your sauce. With this Fontana White Chocolate Mocha Sauce, you can enjoy the flavor of Starbucks at home for about a fifth of the price!

This Starbucks sauce is used in some of the best Starbucks Chocolate Drinks.

No products found.

#3. Best caramel syrup for coffee: DaVinci Gourmet Caramel Sauce

Things we like:

• Creamy gourmet caramel flavor
• 64 ounces
• Full-bodied sauce perfect for toppings
• Inexpensive

Things we don’t like:

• This product contains milk, so it is not vegan.
• Does not include a pump.

Review:

The DaVinci Gourmet Caramel Sauce is one of the best caramel coffee syrups on the market. The thick sauce contains heavy cream and natural flavors for a tasty addition to coffee beverages. Unlike thin syrups that quickly sink to the bottom of your glass, this full-bodied sauce is perfect for adding a creative design to the top of cold foam or whipped cream.

DaVinci is a top gourmet brand and a favorite among chefs and baristas in many coffee shops and restaurants. With 64 ounces in one bottle, create plenty of caramel-flavored coffees or add elegant toppings to drinks. 

Combine Torani’s Vanilla Syrup with DaVinci’s rich caramel sauce to create a Starbucks-style caramel macchiato.

Last update on 2024-12-04

#4. Best pumpkin coffee syrup: Monin Pumpkin Pie Syrup

Things we like: 

• Made with Pure Cane Sugar
• Resembles Starbucks’ Pumpkin Spice Sauce
• Includes real pumpkin puree
• No artificial ingredients
• Non-GMO, Gluten-Free, Kosher

Things we don’t like:

• This syrup has a thinner texture than Starbucks PSL sauce.

Review:

Pumpkin Spice Latte fans look forward to the end of summer when their favorite beverage magically reappears on the Starbucks menu. However, in the off-season, you can make a Pumpkin Spice drink at home whenever you want! In the dog days of summer, an iced pumpkin spice latte can help you keep cool. 

Starbucks, unfortunately, doesn’t sell its syrup to the public. However, we compared the ingredients in Starbucks Pumpkin Spice Sauce to other syrups and found a close cousin in Monin Pumpkin Pie Syrup. Like Starbucks’ PSL, this Monin coffee syrup includes real pumpkin puree, cinnamon, nutmeg, and ginger. It has an excellent flavor without a bitter aftertaste. 

This syrup is thinner than Starbucks’ thick sauce. However, the lighter consistency of Monin’s Pumpkin Pie Syrup is perfect for iced beverages.

Monin also has many other fun flavors to try in your coffee, such as Maple Spice, Green Mint, Toffee Nut, Gingerbread, and Caramel.

Last update on 2024-12-04

#5. Best coffee syrup for Keto and dieting: NuNaturals Sugar-Free Simple Stevia Syrup 

Things we like:

• Plant-based sweetener
• Simple syrup flavor
• 385 servings
• No sugar, zero calories, and zero carbs
• Vegan, Keto-friendly
• No artificial aftertaste

Things we don’t like:

• Not as strong as other brands

Review: 

One of the hardest parts of dieting is giving up sugar. Going off sugar cold-turkey can leave you with cravings and withdrawals. If you want to get healthy, you can keep a sugar-habit in check with this Keto-friendly NuNaturals Sugar-Free Syrup. 

This syrup is made with zero grams of sugar. However, instead of adding chemicals as a sugar-replacement, this syrup uses stevia to satisfy your sweet tooth. You’ll still get the sweet flavor you love without a significant impact on blood sugar or insulin levels. Many dieters also choose stevia-based sweeteners during intermittent fasting. 

This NuNaturals simple syrup is also a great choice for experimenting with flavored coffee. Since it doesn’t have a flavor of its own, it allows the aroma of your coffee beans to shine through. Besides sweetening your coffee, you can also use this syrup on pancakes, yogurt, or in milkshakes.

Whether you are on a strict diet, or just trying to make healthier choices, this NuNaturals Sugar-Free Syrup can be a delicious choice. 

Last update on 2024-12-04

#6. Best coffee syrup for coffee milk and iced coffee: Dave’s Original All-Natural Cold Brewed Coffee Syrup

Things we like:

• 16 ounces
• Made with pure cane sugar and cold brewed coffee
• Includes caffeine
• Preserves coffee flavor in iced beverages

Things we don’t like:

• Not a cold-brew coffee concentrate.
• More expensive than other brands

Review: 

Have you ever tried a coffee syrup that is flavored with coffee? This Original All-Natural Cold Brewed Coffee Syrup actually includes coffee in the recipe. It was originally crafted for Rhode Island’s state drink, “coffee milk.” This drink is just sweetened milk with a small amount of coffee and appeals to both kids and adults alike. Also, if your iced coffee tends to taste watered down after adding milk and ice, this coffee-based syrup can add that boost of coffee flavor you crave. You can use it to create a dirty chai, different from dirty coffee, or add it to baked goods.

Dave’s hand roasts small batches of coffee, creates a cold brew, and then simmers it with cane sugar until it thickens. The result is a rich-flavored syrup that only adds to the flavor of your favorite coffee. A small amount of this syrup can turn even a bland brew into something delicious.

Last update on 2024-12-04

#7. Best lavender coffee syrup: Wäbry Organic Lavender Syrup 

Things we like:

• Flavored with real lavender flowers
• Sweetened with organic evaporated cane juice
• USDA Organic-certified ingredients
• Vegan-friendly
• Non-GMO, dye-free, gluten-free
• A portion of the proceeds from each bottle helps feed hungry children

Things we don’t like:

• Not thick enough to use as a topping or pancake syrup.

Review:

The Wabry brand uses natural and organic ingredients for a difference you can taste. While many lavender syrups are full of artificial flavorings, Wabry’s Organic Lavender Syrup uses real lavender flowers in its recipe. Instead of corn syrup, Wabry uses evaporated cane juice as a healthier option. This flavorful lavender syrup is a light, refreshing addition to an iced latte or a hot London Fog.

Wabry may be a lesser-known brand compared to Torani, DaVinci, Monin, and others. However, those who have tasted Wabry’s natural syrups are instant fans.

Last update on 2024-12-04

#8. Best hazelnut coffee syrup: Sonoma Syrup Co Vanilla Hazelnut Syrup

Things we like:

• Roasted natural Hazelnut with Tahitian Vanilla
• Sweetened with pure cane sugar
• No Artificial Flavors, colors, or preservatives
• Handcrafted in Small Batches
• Made in the U.S.

Things we don’t like:

• Light vanilla flavor

Review:

This Sonoma Simple Syrup is handcrafted in small batches and infused with Vanilla Hazelnut. Instead of using corn syrup like many competitors, Sonoma uses pure cane sugar for a smoother taste. 

The lightly roasted flavor adds a slight punch to coffee drinks without overwhelming the natural coffee tastes. You can also combine this versatile syrup with other syrups and sauces to create unique recipes. 

Although this Vanilla Hazelnut Syrup is more expensive than many brands, the smooth, balanced flavor is worth trying.

Last update on 2024-12-04

#9. Best coffee syrup for vegans: Sunny Sky Upouria 100% Vegan Alert Functional Syrup

Things we like:

• No artificial sweeteners or flavors
• 100% vegan
• Gluten-free
• Contains natural energizers: Ginkgo Biloba, Ginseng, Vitamin C, and B-12
• Includes a pump
• Halal & Kosher Certified

Things we don’t like:

• Some bitterness.

Review:

The Sunny Sky Upouria Alert Functional Syrup can add an extra energy boost to your favorite caffeinated beverage. Besides adding sweetness, it contains energizers such as Ginkgo Biloba, Ginseng, Vitamin C, and B-12. This syrup is 100 percent vegan and gluten-free. 

Use the pump to add a shot of sweetness to your cup of decaf or regular coffee. This Upouria syrup can keep you alert and awake for longer.

Last update on 2024-12-04

#10. Best sugar-free coffee syrup: Jordan’s Skinny Syrups | Classic Syrup Sampler

Things we like:

• The sampler includes six flavors: Mocha, Vanilla, Butter Toffee, Caramel, Salted Caramel, and Hazelnut
• 0g sugar, 0 calories, and 0 carbs
• Gluten-free, non-GMO
• Kosher and keto-friendly
• Crafted in the USA

Things we don’t like:

• Some artificial aftertaste

Review:

Why try one syrup when you can try six? This Jordan’s Skinny Syrup Sampler contains the classic coffee syrups you love. The 25.4 Fl Oz bottles include Mocha, Vanilla, Butter Toffee, Caramel, Salted Caramel, and Hazelnut flavors. These coffee syrups contain zero grams of sugar, making them popular for diabetics and dieters. 

The drawback is that a picky palate may detect a slightly artificial aftertaste. However, with over 15,000 Amazon reviews, these sugar-free syrups maintain an excellent rating of 4.6 stars. With Jordan’s Skinny Syrups, you can enjoy your favorite coffee syrup flavors without worrying about a spike in your blood sugar.

Last update on 2024-12-04

The best coffee syrup recipe for making specialty drinks at home

If you run out of your favorite brand of coffee syrup at home, you can always make your own while you wait for your next shipment. A simple coffee syrup contains only two main ingredients: Sugar and water. Add equal parts of water and sugar to a pan, then let it simmer until the sugar dissolves. Pull the syrup off the heat when many bubbles rise to the surface. As it cools, the syrup will continue to thicken. 

You can use any type of sugar you have on hand. However, white, granulated cane sugar tends to yield the best consistency. Use more sugar for a thicker pancake-type syrup and less for a thinner syrup.

Simple syrup dissolves easily into drinks, and the flavor melds nicely with flavored coffees. To create flavored syrups, add the appropriate ingredients while the sugar and water simmer together. You can infuse the syrup with lavender flowers, vanilla beans, or cinnamon sticks and cloves. When the syrup thickens, strain out the pieces and try a spoonful in your coffee cup.

How to find the best coffee syrups: Buyers guide

Are you trying to narrow down all of your coffee syrup options? We’ve created a buyer’s guide to help you decide. Let’s look at some tips for finding your best coffee syrup.

How does it taste?

The main purpose of coffee syrup is to complement the flavor of your favorite cup of Joe. A syrup can be vegan, keto, and non-GMO, but if it clashes with your coffee, it still fails its job. Look for brands that choose high-quality ingredients, and check out the customer rating section before making your final decision. 

What kind of sweetener is in the coffee syrup?

Corn syrup is often part of the recipe in some of the best-selling coffee syrups. When it comes to taste, corn syrup-based sauces pale when you compare them to pure cane sugar syrups. 

If you want a no-sugar option, try a natural stevia syrup or a traditional sugar-free option. Be aware that many syrups with artificial sweeteners can leave a bitter aftertaste in your mouth. Take a look at the ingredient list before purchasing. 

Pump or no pump?

Many premium syrup and sauce brands include a pump when you order your syrup. A pump lets you make quick measurements as you prepare your favorite drink recipes. However, this helpful feature can also add to the cost. 

You can also purchase a pump separately if your syrup does not have one.  This set of glass Molimoli Coffee Syrup Dispensers allow you to change out labels. Use the bottles to mix syrups and create your own signature blend.

Note: When you store your syrup, you should remove the pump and screw on the lid. A secure lid can help your syrup last up to six times as long.

Wrap up

Now that you have seen some of the best coffee syrups on the market, it’s time to make your final choice. Our overall favorite was Torani’s Vanilla Coffee Syrup. This syrup is made with pure cane syrup and natural flavors. We love that it leaves you with a clean coffee taste and no bitter aftertaste.

However, we also enjoy choosing different brands to mix and match the flavors. With ten delicious syrups, you have a range of combinations and concoctions to try. 

FAQs

Chief Editor